Posts Tagged: security

Deprecating some outdated settings

In MIDAS v4.37, we’re deprecating some outdated privacy and security settings.

In this post, we’ll outline what’s changing and explain the reasons behind the decision to remove these options.

“SSL Access” setting has been removed

SSL Access setting in MIDAS
SSL Access setting in MIDAS

In the early days of the World Wide Web, you connected to websites over “http”.

“http” connections were not secure and could be intercepted. So along came “https”, which allowed visitors to connect to websites over encrypted Secure Socket Layer – or SSL – connections.

However, adoption of “https” was initially slow by the majority of the World Wide Web. Primarily, this was due to SSL certificates being very expensive. Large financial institutions were naturally quick to jump on https. However, the price of SSL certificates put securing websites with https out of reach of the average webmaster. Especially when the cost to renew them every 1-2 years was factored in.

Now, as you may know, we’ve been developing our web based MIDAS room booking software for nearly 20 years now! When we first began to offer a “cloud hosted” booking system to customers (way back in 2007), SSL/https use around the web was not wide spread, and was expensive to implement.

Initially in 2007, we offered our cloud-hosted customers the option of being able to access their hosted MIDAS system over secure https. This was available via an optional (paid) addon for their scheduling system.

By June 2011, we’d recognized the importance and benefit of secure SSL connections for all our customers to their MIDAS systems. We therefore introduced better support for secure SSL connections with MIDAS v3.13.

As part of this, we added a new “SSL Access” setting to v3.13. This allowed administrators to control whether insecure http and/or secure https connections would be permitted to their MIDAS system.

In August 2012, we then took the further decision to include an SSL Certificate to enable secure connections for all our existing and future cloud hosted customers. At the same time, we enforced https connections to all hosted MIDAS system.

Consequently, the “SSL Access” option first introduced in MIDAS v3.13 became redundant for our cloud-hosted customers. Since 2015 and MIDAS v4.09, this option has no longer been available in cloud-hosted editions of our booking system.

In the following years, gradually the cost of SSL certificates reduced. Then in 2016, along came a game-changing service called “Let’s Encrypt“. Let’s Encrypt offered FREE SSL certificates for all. This finally allowed every webmaster the ability to “secure” visitor connections to their websites at zero cost.

In May 2018 we migrated all our cloud-hosted customer’s SSL certificates from expensive GlobalSign certificates to ones issued for free by Let’s Encrypt instead.

Now, in 2024, SSL/https certificates are the norm – in fact, all modern web browsers now alert you if you attempt to visit an insecure website via http.

So whilst we removed the “SSL Access” settings in cloud-hosted MIDAS systems back in 2015, we’re now also removing these settings for self-hosted customers starting with MIDAS v4.37.

“Allowed IP Range” setting has been removed (self hosted editions only)

Allowed IP Range setting in MIDAS
Allowed IP Range setting in MIDAS

The “Allowed IP Range” setting is one of the earliest security settings we provided in our room booking system. In fact, it was first introduced in v1.35 back in August 2007.

The setting allows an administrator to restrict access to their MIDAS system to an IP address or range.

This can be useful if a MIDAS system is hosted on a public-facing web server, which potentially could be accessed by anyone worldwide. The “Allowed IP Range” setting can be used to restrict access to users in your own country, organization, or to just you!

However, one of the limitations of this setting is that it only supports ipv4 address, and not ipv6 addresses.

Also, in the years since this setting was first introduced, other security and firewall products are available which provide greater control over access to websites, apps, and servers.

Therefore, starting with MIDAS v4.37, we have removed the “Allowed IP Range” setting in self-hosted editions.

If you’re a self-hosted customer and wish to restrict access to your MIDAS system by IP address you should consider other options to achieve this.

For instance, on Apache servers, you can easily allow/deny access by ip address/range in your httpd.conf or .htaccess files. For more information, please see Apache’s guidance on access control.

“Do Not Track (dnt)” has been superseded by “Global Privacy Control”

Honor user's Do Not Track preference setting in MIDAS
Honor user’s Do Not Track preference setting in MIDAS

“Do Not Track” – or ‘dnt’ for short – was an official HTTP header first proposed in 2009. It was intended to allow user to opt-out of tracking by websites.

By 2011, all major web browsers had implemented support for the proposed “Do Not Track” features.

In 2017, with the release of MIDAS v4.16, we included an “Honor user’s Do Not Track preference” setting.

If enabled (and if an end-user had also enabled the “Do Not Track” feature in their browser), MIDAS would not log the user’s IP address in the Recent Activity Log.

However, globally, recognition and support of the “Do Not Track” HTTP header by websites was poor. So much so that in January 2019, the “Do No Track” HTTP header was officially deprecated. A month later, Apple removed DNT support from their Safari browser.

Whilst some other browsers still continue to offer a “Do Not Track” setting, it has since been supersede by a new “Global Privacy Control” – or GPC – header.

At time of writing, Global Privacy Control is still classed as an “experimental” and “non standard” technology, and it’s behaviour may change in the future.

But for MIDAS v4.37, we’ll support both DNT and GPC features. The “Honor user’s Do Not Track preference” setting will be renamed to “Honor user’s privacy preferences” to reflect this.

It’s likely that in a future update we’ll fully drop support the deprecated “DNT” header. At time of writing though, as some browsers still support it, we’ll continue to support it too.


Improved Device Detection

Whenever your user account is logged into from a new or unfamiliar device, MIDAS can automatically alert you by email. This additional security feature helps keep your account secure by alerting you to suspicious logins. An unfamiliar login notification includes details of the browser, operating system, IP address, and – with our optional Geolocation addon – location, of the device that’s just logged into your account.

Until now, MIDAS has been unable to distinguish between more recent operating system versions. For example, between Windows 10 and Windows 11, or between MacOS Ventura and Sonoma.

This is because MIDAS has relied on the “User Agent” (UA) string that’s presented by the browser that’s logging in.

Here’s an example of a browser’s “User Agent” string presented to a web server:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.0.0 Safari/537.36

There’s a lot of information there, but essentially, from this string MIDAS can derive that it’s a Windows (64 bit) device, and the browser is Google Chrome 123.

Here’s another example:

Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.15; rv:124.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/124.0

From this, MIDAS can derive that it’s a macOS device, and the browser is Firefox 124.

But wait… can’t MIDAS also determine the exact version of the operating system from these UA strings?

Mac OS X 10.15…. Catalina? …Big Sur? …Monterey? …Ventura?

Doesn’t “Mac OS X 10.15” imply macOS Catalina? ..and doesn’t “Windows NT 10.0” imply Windows 10?

Well, that used to be the case, but not any more!

Modern browsers now “clamp” the versions of more recent macOS/Windows operating systems reported by the User Agent string. For macOS operating systems, the User Agent string will report a maximum of macOS X 10.15. For Windows operating systems, a maximum of Windows 10 will be reported. Browsers no longer natively report the specific version of the operating system they’re running on.

This means that a Chrome browser running on either Windows 10 or Windows 11 will report “Windows NT 10.0”. Similarly, macOS Catalina (10.15), Big Sur (11), Monterey (12), Ventura (13), and Sonoma (14), will all report “Mac OS X 10.15”.

So Windows 10 and 11 are the same then?

In an effort to improve user privacy, browsers have decided to no longer reveal the specific operating system version a user is using when visiting a website, in order to make it harder for websites to “fingerprint” users.

“Fingerprinting” is a technique that some websites employ to uniquely identify and potentially track visitors.

So because of these changes to the way browsers report User Agent strings, it’s been difficult for MIDAS to provide a unfamiliar login notification containing details of exact operating system version that’s been used to login to an account.

But advancements in technology mean that we’ve now been able to make improvements to device detection for MIDAS v4.36.

Utilizing New “Client Hint” technology

Client hints are a set of HTTP request headers that provide useful information about the client such as device type and network conditions. This then allow servers to optimize what is served for those conditions.

Unlike the traditional “User Agent String”, client hints provide a more efficient and privacy preserving way of getting the desired information.

A web server can proactively request the client hint headers they are interested in. The browser can then include the requested headers in subsequent requests.

If the web server upon which a MIDAS system is running proactively requests either the “sec-ch-ua-platform-version” or “ua-platform-version” client hint header, MIDAS can receive details of the user’s operating system version.

Unfamiliar login notifications (if enabled) can then provide much more accurate information as to the operating system of the new device which has logged into your account.

Improved Device Detection in MIDAS v4.36
Improved Device Detection in MIDAS v4.36

Web Server Configuration

Because a web server has to proactively request these new client headers in order for browsers to respond to them, servers have to be configured accordingly.

All of our cloud-hosted nodes have been appropriately configured. Our client servers now proactively request the necessary Client Hint headers. This in turn means that all cloud hosted users can start to take advantage of these improvements to device detection and unfamiliar login notifications.

For self-hosted customers, a small configuration change to the web server when your MIDAS system is running from is required.

Details of the configuration change you’ll need to make can be found in our KB article, How to configure your server for Client Hints.


Proposal to drop TLS 1.2 support in early 2025

Proposal to deprecate Transport Layer Security TLS 1.2

Transport Layer Security – or “TLS”- is a cryptographic mechanism to facilitate secure connections and communications across the internet. For example, the https network connection between your device and secure websites or applications, like MIDAS.

Several incarnations of the Transport Layer Security protocol have been developed over the years, the most recent being 1.3:

ProtocolReleasedCurrent Status
TLS 1.01999Deprecated
TLS 1.12006Deprecated
TLS 1.22008In use since 2008
TLS 1.32018In use since 2018
TLS Protocol History

TLS 1.0 and 1.1 are now considered “legacy protocols” and “weak” by today’s cryptographic standards. That’s because they’re susceptible to several vulnerabilities. Modern web browsers automatically default to preferring more secure TLS 1.2 and 1.3 connections. In fact, they may even display a warning when connecting to a website that only supports the now obsolete TLS 1.0/1.1 protocols.

As security and cryptographic standards have evolved over the years, we have too! We’ve previously dropped support for TLS 1.0 connections to our network in 2017. We then subsequently dropped support for TLS 1.1 connections in 2020.

As part of our ongoing commitment to security, we’re now proposing to also deprecate support for TLS 1.2 connections to our client servers in early 2025. Going forward, we propose to only support TLS 1.3 (the latest Transport Layer Security protocol version) connections.

But wait.. isn’t TLS 1.2 still considered secure?

In the past few years, researchers have discovered cryptographic weakness in the ciphers and algorithms that TLS 1.2 uses.

While TLS 1.2 can still be used, it is no longer considered the most secure option. TLS 1.2 is only considered “safe” when weak ciphers and algorithms are removed.

On the other hand, TLS 1.3 supports the latest modern encryption with stronger encryption algorithms and more robust authentication mechanisms. TLS 1.3 is currently the most secure TLS version. At time of writing, TLS 1.3 currently has no known vulnerabilities, and also offers performance improvements over TLS 1.2.

When will TLS 1.2 be deprecated?

At time of writing, there has been no date announced as to when TLS 1.2 will be officially deprecated.

However, one day TLS 1.2 will become obsolete, just as its predecessors TLS 1.1 and TLS 1.0 have become.

TLS 1.3 is currently the most secure TLS version. We’re keen to aid its adoption and to ensure the most secure connections to our network and servers. This is why we’re proposing to stop supporting older TLS 1.2 connections in 2025.

What impact would disabling TLS 1.2 support have?

Most modern browsers and operating systems support TLS 1.3.

Therefore, the vast majority of users will be unaffected by our proposal to switch off support for TLS 1.2 in early 2025. However, if you’re using an older device or operating system, you may need to take action.

Here’s a list of browsers and devices that will be affected when TLS 1.2 connections are blocked:

  • Internet Explorer: All versions of Internet Explorer do not support TLS 1.3. This should not impact any of our users, as our MIDAS software has not been supported in IE since 2019.
  • Edge Legacy: Versions of Edge Legacy prior to April 2018 do not support TLS 1.3. Users would need to update to a newer version of Edge or a different browser.
  • Safari on macOS 10.12 Sierra or earlier: These older macOS versions do not support TLS 1.3 in Safari. Users would need to upgrade their macOS or use a different browser.
  • Very old versions of other browsers: Browsers that haven’t been updated in several years might not support TLS 1.3.
  • Older Android devices: Devices running Android 9 (and earlier versions) do not support TLS 1.3.
  • Older iOS devices: Devices running iOS 12 (and earlier versions) do not support TLS 1.3.

Web browsers and devices that do support TLS 1.3:

  • Microsoft Edge (current versions): Supported since April 2018 (Edge 79+)
  • Google Chrome: Supported since April 2018 (Chrome 70+)
  • Mozilla Firefox: Supported since October 2017 (Firefox 63+)
  • Apple Safari (on macOS 10.13 High Sierra or later): Supported since September 2018 (Safari 14+)
  • Opera: Supported since April 2018 (Opera 57+)
  • Android: Android 10 (or later)
  • iOS: iOS 13 (or later)

Important Information For Hosted API users:

If you’re a cloud-hosted MIDAS customer utilizing the optional MIDAS API you may need to take action before TLS 1.2 connections to our network are disabled in early 2025.

You’ll need to ensure that your applications and the underlying programming language you develop in can support (and are correctly configured for) TLS 1.2 connections.

For instance Java 7 (1.7) (and lower) and .NET 4.7 (and lower) languages don’t support TLS 1.1/1.2.

If your applications/programming languages do not support TLS 1.3 encryption, your MIDAS API calls will begin to fail in early 2025 once we disable TLS 1.2 support across our network.

Please refer to the vendor of your programming language if you’re unsure whether it supports TLS 1.3, or for assistance enabling such support in your development environment.

Remind me again.. when is this all happening?

Currently, we are proposing to drop support for TLS 1.2 connections to our network in early 2025.

We have not fixed a specific date in 2025 for this as yet (as we want to hear from you – see below).

However, anything can change over the course of a year. Should new vulnerabilities be discovered in TLS 1.2 during 2024, this may prompt us to bring our plans to deprecate 1.2 support forward.

We Want To Hear From You!

We are currently only proposing to deprecate TLS 1.2 connections to our network in early 2025.

However, we’re open to feedback from you our users in the meantime.

If you feel you have a particular usage case that would require continued reliance on TLS 1.2 support, please reach out to us to discuss.


Schedule regular Security Audits

You may not know, but MIDAS includes a built-in “Security Audit” tool.

This allows you to perform a quick and on-demand security analysis of your MIDAS system.

Perform a detailed Security Audit of your MIDAS room booking system
Perform a detailed Security Audit of your MIDAS room booking system

First introduced with the release of MIDAS v4.13 in 2016, the “Security Audit” tool tests a number of key metrics of your MIDAS booking system.

The audit checks your MySQL / MariaDB setup, MIDAS files, and recommended MIDAS security settings.

It provides a detailed report with appropriate advisories for hardening the security of your MIDAS system.

When the Security Audit was first introduced, it analyzed 15 metrics. Today, that number has increased to over 20.

For MIDAS v4.33, the audit now additionally also…

  • Indicates the number of recently failed login attempts to your MIDAS system.
  • Checks whether Geofenced logins have been enabled.

But the biggest improvement to Security Audits for MIDAS v4.33 is the ability to schedule regular automated security audits.

Until now, a Security Audit could only be manually initiated (via MIDAS Admin Options → Manage MIDAS → Security → Perform a Security Audit)

From MIDAS v4.33, you can now use Scheduled Tasks to automatically run a Security Audit and email you the results. Audits can be configured to run every 7, 14, 30, 60, or 90 days.

Schedule automated security audits of your MIDAS booking system
Schedule automated security audits of your MIDAS booking system